A disappointing version of Dr. Seuss's book. Directed by Chuck Jones, the genius behind How the Grinch Stole Christmas! (1966) (TV) , another Seuss Book, and many of the best Warner Bros cartoons. This is my favorite Seuss book, and I was surprised to see them deviate from the story. After watching the 3D version, Horton Hears a Who! (2008), and being disappointed with their straying from the storyline, I had high hopes that Jones would follow what is a perfect tale of acceptance and heroism. I'm not sure of the reason to change character names and dialogue, but it added nothing.I was excited to see the 2008 version, from the moment I saw the first stills, it looked perfect, great designs and rendering, but they felt the need to add unnecessary plot diversions, I suppose to add humor and length to the show. Possibly this is the same for Jones's version.
Unlike the 3D version I didn't like the character design and animation. With the Grinch, he showed that he could make a complete and classic Seuss show, but he missed on this one. In addition, the music chosen was very irritating and distracting. And while I usually like the voice of Hans Conried, he was out of place in this show.
One other thing bothered me about this one, while the book has a strong moral tone to it, you don't feel confronted by it. The cartoon on the other hand seems to be trying to be make a political statement and hits you over the head with it.
1 ½ out of 5
www.imdb.com
No comments:
Post a Comment